In the volatile climate of the Bismarck-Mandan region, your roof is more than a structural necessity—it is a long-term financial investment. Choosing between metal roofing and asphalt shingles requires a careful balance of upfront cost, expected lifespan, and the ability to survive North Dakota’s specific weather threats. While asphalt shingles remain the most popular choice for their immediate affordability and versatility, metal roofing is increasingly seen as the ultimate “lifetime” solution due to its superior durability and minimal maintenance requirements.
Deciding which material offers the best value depends on how long you plan to stay in your home and your tolerance for storm-related repairs. At Vander Wal Contracting, we install both systems with an emphasis on engineering a layered defense that can withstand the heavy snow loads and high-wind uplift common to our prairie landscape.
Durable Asphalt Shingle Systems: Performance and Versatility
For many homeowners, high-quality asphalt shingles offer the perfect middle ground. Modern architectural or dimensional shingles have evolved significantly, offering a layered, textured look that enhances curb appeal while providing a robust shield against the elements.
At Vander Wal Contracting, we exclusively recommend architectural shingles over traditional 3-tab versions. These shingles feature heavier construction and better Class 4 Impact Resistance ratings, making them far more capable of surviving a North Dakota hail event. When combined with a professional installation—including synthetic underlayment and ice and water shields—asphalt remains a reliable, cost-effective defense.
Premium Metal Roofing: The “Lifetime” Solution
For clients seeking maximum longevity, metal roofing is the superior choice. In a climate where sudden temperature swings cause other materials to warp or crack, metal remains stable and impervious.
We specialize in Standing Seam Metal, which is the preferred choice for residential and commercial properties alike. Because the panels are connected with raised, interlocking seams, the fasteners are hidden from the elements. This creates a virtually watertight barrier that can last 50 years or more, effectively making it the last roof you will ever need to buy.
Direct Comparison: Metal vs. Asphalt Shingles
| Feature | Asphalt Shingle Systems | Premium Metal Roofing |
| Average Lifespan | 20–25 Years | 50+ Years |
| Upfront Cost | Lower initial investment | Higher initial investment |
| Maintenance | Requires periodic inspection | Virtually zero maintenance |
| Wind Resistance | High (with proper fastening) | Superior (Interlocking panels) |
| Snow Shedding | Snow tends to sit on shingles | Snow slides off easily |
| Impact Resistance | Good (Class 4 available) | Excellent (Resists puncturing) |
The North Dakota Factor: Snow and Wind
The Midwest weather cycle places unique stresses on a roof that go beyond simple rain protection.
- Snow Management: Metal roofs are naturally “slippery,” allowing snow to slide off before it can build up and contribute to ice dam formation.
- Wind Uplift: High winds in the Bismarck area can catch the edges of asphalt shingles if they aren’t sealed properly. Metal panels, specifically standing seam, are mechanically fastened and locked together, making them incredibly difficult for wind to penetrate.
- Thermal Expansion: Metal handles the -30°F to 90°F temperature swings of North Dakota with ease, whereas asphalt can become brittle over time due to constant expansion and contraction.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a metal roof louder during rain or hail?
This is a common myth. When installed with high-quality underlayment and over a solid roof deck and attic space, a metal roof is no louder than a shingle roof. The attic insulation acts as a natural sound barrier.
Does a metal roof increase my home’s value?
Yes. A metal roof is a massive selling point for future buyers in North Dakota, as it represents a permanent solution to roofing concerns. Many insurance companies also offer premium discounts for impact-resistant metal roofs.
Will asphalt shingles look “cheap” compared to metal?
Not at all. Modern architectural shingles come in a wide array of colors and style profiles that can mimic the look of wood shakes or slate, providing a premium aesthetic at a lower price point.
Can a metal roof be installed over my old shingles?
While possible in some cases, Vander Wal Contracting typically recommends a full tear-off. This allows us to inspect the decking for rot and ensure the new “weather-tight envelope” is built on a solid foundation.
Which is better for preventing ice dams?
Metal roofing is generally superior for ice dam prevention because it sheds snow quickly and does not allow water to “grip” the surface. However, both systems require proper attic ventilation to function perfectly in winter.
What is the “Class 4” rating?
This is the highest rating for impact resistance. It means the material has been tested to withstand the impact of large hailstones without cracking or failing. We offer this rating in both high-end shingles and metal systems.
Choosing between metal and asphalt is a decision based on your long-term goals. If you are looking for a cost-effective, high-performance roof to protect your home for the next two decades, asphalt shingles are an excellent choice. If you want a “one-and-done” solution that offers maximum durability and energy efficiency for a lifetime, metal is the clear winner.
By: Vander Wal Contracting Editorial Team
Last Updated: January 21, 2026
Credentials: Bismarck’s trusted roofers specializing in high-performance asphalt and metal systems built for the North Dakota climate.